The Eerie Islanders is one of the two original teams competing in Totally Teen Island. The team consisted of Brendan, Chrissy, Devon, Jazmyn, Kai, Luis, ScrappyDoo, and Madilynn before the teams were split up in episode 4.
|Name||Gender||Rank Team||Rank Voted Off||Episode Eliminated||Reason voted off|
|ScrappyDoo||Male||8th||18th||Feeding Time||He annoyed his teammates with his antics.|
|Jazmyn||Female||7th||13th||Into the Woods||She failed to compete so her team voted for her.|
|Devon||Male||6th||10th||Muddy Mud Mud||Everyone saw him as a threat.|
|Luis||Male||5th||8th||Help the Dakotazoid||Luis was seen as a threat.|
|Kai||Female||4th||6th||Double the Trouble||She was seen as a huge threat.|
|Chrissy||Female||3rd||3rd||Battle of the Campers||She didn't win as much votes as te other finalists|
|Madilynn||Female||1st||1st||Battle of the Campers||Tied with Brendan for the season win!|
|Brendan||Male||1st||1st||Battle of the Campers||Tied with Madi for the season win!|
- ScrappyDoo is the only member to be eliminated before the team swap.
- Brendan and Kai are the only members to be switched to the Golden Geese.
- Jazymn, Devon, Luis, Kai, Chrissy, and Madilynn switched to the Speedy Sharks.
- Both season winners are on this team.
- Also, the all of the Finalists were on this team.